The Situation of Birthers’ Belief
Posted by The Situationist Staff on August 11, 2009
Scientific American has an interesting, “60-Second Podcast” by Steve Mirsky about research by Situationist Contributor Mahzarin Banaji and San Diego State’s Thierry Devos finding that white Americans inherently regard white Europeans as somehow more “American” than Asian- or African-Americans. Here are some excerpts from the podcast, which you can link to here.
* * *
The so-called birthers can’t accept that President Obama is really a natural-born American citizen. Part of what’s behind this seemingly irrational belief may lie in what’s called implicit social cognition—the deep-rooted assumptions we all carry around, and may act on without realizing it.
Harvard’s Mahzarin Banaji studies such implicit cognition. Last fall she talked to journalists at the annual conference of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing about research into bias against Asian-Americans. “So we thought, what if we picked Asians who are very well known to be American. What about Connie Chung? Are they going to be seen as less American than, let’s say, Hugh Grant? And so we thought this was a bizarre study to do but we did it anyway.”
Amazingly, white Americans did see a white European like Hugh Grant as being somehow more American than the Asian-American Connie Chung. And similar research in 2008 found that whites thought of ex-British Prime Minister Tony Blair as somehow more American than Obama. So the mental framework to believe that Obama is foreign probably was, to use a health care term, a preexisting condition.
* * *
To read a closely related Situationist post, see “The Situation of Being ‘(un)American’.”
For some posts examining the the role of implicit associations in elections, see “Patricia Devine on Resisting Implicit Associations,” “The Interior Situation of Undecided Voters,” “On Being a Mindful Voter,” “Lopez-Torres, Justice Scalia, and the Situation of Elections,” “Your Brain on Politics,” “Implicit Associations in the 2008 Presidential Election,” “The Situation of Political Animals,” “Political Psychology in 2008,” “Perceptions of Racial Divide,The Psychology of Barack Obama as the Antichrist,” and “The Interior Situation of Undecided Voters.”
To review all of the previous Situationist posts discussing implicit associations click on the “Implicit Associations” category in the right margin, or, for a list of such posts, click here. For other Situationist posts on the 2008 Presidential Election, click here.
This entry was posted on August 11, 2009 at 12:01 am and is filed under Implicit Associations, Podcasts, Social Psychology. Tagged: birthers, Implicit Associations, Mahzarin Banaji, race. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.